Just looking at the list of TSX-traded debentures (100 issues from 63 companies), price-wise, the company trading at the lowest price is Surge Energy (TSX: SGY). Their debentures (a total of $79 million, about half of which matures in the end of December 2022) are trading just a shade above 30 cents on the dollar.
Usually when a company’s debt is trading that low, a recapitalization is looming. Indeed, for Surge, it is a likely scenario, if not an outright CCAA proceeding. Q2-2020 was very rough for all oil producers, with WTIC going negative and all the Covid fallout. For Surge, the last corporate snapshot on July 30, 2020 showed a fairly dire financial picture, specifically the $307 million in senior bank debt. This credit facility goes to a redetermination on December 2020, and is otherwise payable on March 2021.
Although in a ‘normal’ environment, the corporation is cash flow positive (even after the capex), it isn’t going to be nearly enough to address the bank debt, let alone when the convertible debentures are due. The absolute amount of product being produced (17k boe equivalent with 80% crude) is well below what it needs to be to support the amount of financial leverage. Hence, the convertible debentures, being very low on the pecking order, are going to be incredibly disadvantaged if it comes to a recapitalization proposal, and are sure to be wiped clean in a CCAA arrangement. Hence, this is why they are trading in the low 30’s.
There is a winning scenario, and that involves a surge (pun intended) in oil prices. Right now the corporation is hoping they get bailed out by the commodity market before the banks close in for the kill.
I took a small loss in September bailing out what was a very small position in the debentures I took post-COVID. Sometimes debt is cheap for a reason! Or another way – just because it’s cheap doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a good value!
The next companies in line in terms of having the lowest trading prices: Supreme Cannabis (FIRE.DB), Invesque (IVQ.DB.U/.V), and Chorus Aviation (CJR.DB.A), all roughly in the upper 40’s or 50’s, and all for fairly obvious reasons when examining the businesses in question.