Tag: CWB

Crown Capital Partners debenture refinancing proposal

A hat-tip to Frank L. for pointing out that Crown Capital Partners (TSX: CRWN), a little-known microcap financing company, on April 11, 2023 issued a proposal to refinance their $20 million face value of convertible debentures trading as (TSX: CRWN.DB).

The salient features they are offering are:

* Extending the maturity date of the Debentures from June 30, 2023 to December 31, 2024;
* Amending the interest rate on the Debentures from 6% to 10% effective July 1, 2023;
* Removing the conversion right of the Debentureholders; and
* Removing the right of the Corporation to repay the principal amount of the Debentures in common shares of the Corporation (“Common Shares”) on the new maturity date or any redemption date.

This company wasn’t on my radar but I gave it a closer look and glossed through their annual financial statement.

First, I noticed that there is quite a bit of consolidation going on in their entity (which means it takes a lot of time to dig through – time I, quite frankly, did not want to spend). A material amount of their assets are in the non-current category consisting of their investments (Crown Partners Fund, leased distributed power equipment, and other property and equipment). Needless to say it isn’t exactly of the variety that you can put it up on Ebay and dump for some quick cash.

The other thing that struck out at me is that they had $7.2 million cash on their balance sheet, and $11.9 million in mortgages payable (November 2023), $18 million in credit facilities (long-dated), and of course the $20 million in convertible debentures.

The credit facility’s fine print, is the following:

Effective February 7, 2023, the Corporation entered into a new senior secured corporate credit facility with Canadian Western Bank of up to $43,500 to be used to fund a full repayment and cancellation of lender commitments in respect of the Crown Credit Facility, support working capital and growth capital requirements of the Corporation and its operating businesses, and to fund the Corporation’s remaining capital commitment in respect of Crown Power Fund. The new senior secured corporate credit facility replaced the Crown Credit Facility and includes an amortizing term loan of up to $30,000 with a maturity date of February 7, 2028, an operating loan of up to $10,000 with availability subject to margin condition restrictions, and a letter of credit facility of up to $3,500. The term loan is comprised of an initial advance of $25,000 plus $5,000 to be advanced upon request by the Corporation prior to June 30, 2023. The term loan and the operating loan provide financing at variable interest rates based on Prime Rate plus 165 bps to 265 bps and 200 bps to 300 bps, respectively, and feature a customary set of covenants.

(You want to know why Canadian Western Bank (TSX: CWB) is trading like it will go First Republic Bank (NYSE: FRC) any moment?)

Pay attention to the rate paid. Prime is 670bps at the moment, so the term loan is 8.35% to 9.35% and the operating loan is 8.7% to 9.7%, floating.

In addition, you have the mortgage payable which has the following fine print:

Effective May 27, 2022, the Corporation entered into an agreement for a mortgage payable of $11,900 that is secured by the value of property under development, has a maturity date of November 30, 2023, and bears interest based on Prime Rate plus 570 bps (with a floor of 8.40%) per annum.

Prime plus 570bps is a 12.4% mortgage! Holy moly!

So why on planet earth would the convertible debenture holders agree to an unsecured 10% coupon when clearly the cost of capital for the other secured lending the corporation is taking is at much higher rates and you lose the (nearer) maturity date advantage? They generously offer a 1% consent fee for a yes vote!

The last thing I’ll point out is that they spent $24.8 million on share repurchases over the past two calendar years. Money that could have been better spent on… perhaps redeeming this debt?

The debentures are really illiquid, the stock is unshortable, and I have no positions in this company, nor do I intend on taking any.

Canadian Bank Stocks

Bank financial institutions usually make money by borrowing short and lending long (i.e. having their cost of capital at the short-term interest rate, while earning money with the long-term interest rate).  The flattening yield curve is making it more difficult for financial institutions to capture this spread and this is reflected in what we see in Canadian bank stocks.

Looking at the six majors (TD, BNS, RY, CM, BMO and semi-major NA), they are all down for the year.  Looking at the juniors (CWB and LB), they are also down, especially in LB’s case (which has some other business operation issues that I will not get into this post, but suffice to say there is a reason why it is trading at less than 75% of book and a P/E of 8).

There are also other quasi-banks (e.g. EQB, HCG, FN – yes, I know FN is not a bank, etc.) that appear to be doing reasonably well despite their obvious reliance on the stability of the Canadian mortgage market.

Some people are advocating that this is a good time to get into the sector as traditionally most of Canada’s big banks have proven to be stable in history, and the big banks are making record amounts of profits.

Assuming you had to be locked into an investment in these Canadian banks, the proper question to answer is whether these institutions will continue making money at the rate they have been making it historically that justify their valuation.  They look cheap from a historical perspective, but just relying on historical analysis is a very dangerous method of investing.  There is a lot of competition in the financial sector domain and I am not sure whether forward looking, profitability will be as strong as it has been in the past half decade.  The easy money appears to have been made.

In general, I would not be surprised at all to see the major banks tread water price-wise for the next few years or even see investors today take small unrealized capital losses over that time frame while clipping their 4-5% dividend coupons.

Finally, I will clarify this post does not take into context the insurance sector (e.g. MFC, SLF, etc.) which has their own dynamics.  I also do not hold anything mentioned in this post, although I have taken a hard look at LB and CWB recently.