The COVID quarter where everything gets written off

Most companies have a fiscal year corresponding with the calendar, and most of them will be reporting April to June results in the last week of July and in early August.

Q1’s results were in the onset of COVID-19, so results were only partially affected (the sanctions required due to the pandemic really only took effect in the middle of March).

Q2 will contain the full brunt of the economic consequences of COVID-19.

The results posted are going to be horrible for a lot of companies, especially on a GAAP basis. You’re going to see a whole bunch of write-downs of various assets that have been lingering on balance sheets for far too long, but Q2 will be the best time to formally impair them and get past mistakes out of the public consciousness.

The markets are not going to care. This has long since been baked in.

The next consequence of this is that you’re going to see headline computer generated metrics from company financial statements (price to earnings, EPS, etc.) over the next twelve months get wildly misstated due to the inevitable Q2 reporting of losses. This will also affect ROE/ROA, growth percentages, and almost anything relating to earnings in the calculation.

As a result, stock screens looking for value will be twisted unless if forward-looking adjustments can be made. A common forward-looking metric is “consensus analyst estimates”, but this figure is what an investor is looking as a rough short-term measuring stick in relation to the price the market is offering (indeed, if something looks ‘cheap’ solely on the basis of price to consensus analyst estimates, I’d view that much more as an alarm bell than a reason to buy).

The contamination of financial data coming from the COVID quarter will be the worst since the 2008-2009 financial crisis. While individual stock selection is always important, the COVID quarter should create an even better environment for stock selection than other times.