Magna International is a dual-class stock that retained control of the corporation in the Stronach family.
The Canada Pension Plan is unhappy that the corporation recently agreed to a deal with the Stronach trust to convert their class of voting stock into regular common stock, at a very high premium – $300 million in cash, plus 9 million class A shares. At today’s prices for class A shares, this works out to approximately $920 million in exchange for the voting rights of the company.
Suffice to say, shareholders are not too happy about the matters, including the Canada Pension Plan.
However, this should be a huge lesson to those that invest in majority-controlled companies – your interests have to line up with the interests of the majority holder in order for you to make any headway on your investment. In the case of Magna, its majority holder (Stronach) clearly wants as much cash and liquidity out of the corporation as possible – and the common shareholders, including those invested in the Canada Pension Plan, will be paying the price.
What is interesting, however, is that the deal was structured in a politically astute manner – common shares went up after the announcement since Magna was already trading at a discount due to the adverse interests of the majority holder. It is the company, however, that will be paying the price to buy out the Stronach voting stake.
If you have shares in companies that are majority controlled, pay careful attention to these agency issues.