Cenovus Energy’s relatively small dividend

Cenovus Energy (TSX: CVE) is Canada’s second largest oil producer (behind CNQ), featuring two flagship oil sands projects, Christina Lake and Foster Creek. Unlike CNQ, they have downstream capacity just a shade short of their production levels. Needless to say they have been producing a lot of cash flow.

Compared to the top three (CNQ, Suncor and CVE), Cenovus’ dividend has been relatively paltry – the yield has been less than 2% and a very small fraction of the company’s free cash flow.

You might have been wondering why, and it likely concerns the warrant indenture. Specifically, the warrants have a price adjustment if “Dividends paid in the ordinary course” exceeds a certain level:

in the aggregate, the greater of: (i) (a) for the 2021 financial year, $170 million; and (b) for financial years after 2021, 150% of the aggregate amount of the dividends paid by the Corporation on its Common Shares in its immediately preceding financial year which were Dividends Paid in the Ordinary Course for such preceding year;
(ii) 100% of the retained earnings of the Corporation as at the end of its immediately preceding financial year; and
(iii) 100% of the aggregate consolidated net earnings of the Corporation, determined before computation of extraordinary items but after dividends paid on all Common Shares and first preferred shares of the Corporation, for its immediately preceding financial year, in each case calculated in accordance with Canadian generally accepted accounting principles consistent with those applied in the preparation of the most recently completed audited consolidated financial statements of the Corporation;

The relevant clause for 2021 is retained earnings, and it was $878 million at the end of 2021. $878 million divided by 2.016 billion shares outstanding gives you about 43 cents per share, and CVE’s current dividend was raised to 42 cents per share.

For the first half of 2022, retained earnings is sitting at $4.6 billion and this will likely go much higher by year-end. At June 30, CVE had 1.97 billion shares outstanding and thus they can practically increase their regular dividend to match their cash flow once the audited financial statements are released in March of 2023. Until then, they are stuck with their existing dividend and are busy buying back shares and paying down debt in the meantime, in addition to consolidating the 50% share in the Sunrise oil sands and Toledo refinery that they previously did not own. Once they get down to their $4 billion debt target, the company pledged to distribute 100% of its earnings to shareholders – practically behaving like an income trust if you remember those days when Penn West and Pengrowth income trusts were throwing out the cashflow in a similar manner. An annualized $2/share dividend is not out of the question, and this would likely result in the stock trading for higher than what it is currently trading for today.