Rising long-term interest rates

From the Bank of Canada (the 10-year and 5-year government bond yield):

From the end of 2020 (0.67%) to yesterday (0.84%) the 10-year bond yield has risen.

This could just be from the “white noise” of trading. A fixed equity/debt split would surely have resulted in equity selling and fixed income purchasing which to date has not occurred, prices would appear to have done the opposite. US 10-year treasuries are also up about 15bps or so from the beginning of the year.

The impact of rising long-term interest rates have a ripple effect through the market. If the trend continues, you’ll see a dampening effect across the investment spectrum. Right now it is not a lot, but if yields continue to rise another 20bps or so (totally arbitrary guess), more people will start noticing and you’ll start to see momentum effects occur, which would likely be concentrated with price contractions of yield-based instruments (which would have the immediate impact of increasing their yields, but interest rate increases would result in the expense of their ability to borrow money at low rates). Soros’ theory on reflectivity reflexivity really applies here!

The zero rate bound

What is the difference between 0.25% and 0.1%? A 60% drop in the short term interest rates!

Apparently that is the logic of the Bank of Canada mulling a decrease in the target rate, which is currently at 0.25%.

In November, the Reserve Bank of Australia cut its policy rate by 15 basis points to 0.1%, while the Bank of England did the same last March.

While this may not seem like a lot, the mathematics of division when you get close to zero gets really fun. If your limitation is interest expense, then reducing the interest rate by 60% means you can borrow 2.5x more money!

This is a luxury that nations with their own sovereign currencies can perform. In Canada, despite the federal debt ballooning over $1 trillion this fiscal year, public debt charges peaked in 1995-1996 at nearly $50 billion. For the 2020-2021 COVID-19 fiscal year, that interest bite is expected to be about $19.5 billion (table A2.4)!

The low interest rate environment ends when the demand for currency starts to abate and one trigger to this is the onset of inflation.

Nasdaq buying Verafin

News article (Nasdaq to buy Verafin for US$2.75-billion in biggest Canadian software takeover since 2007)

The line that caught my attention was:

The purchase price, at 19.5 times expected 2021 revenue, reflects Verafin’s rapid expansion, with a compound annual revenue growth of approximately 30 per cent over the past three years. Nasdaq expects Verafin to deliver more than US$140-million in revenue in 2021.

No wonder they sold out at the price they did!

Software is all the rage currently and some are trading ridiculously expensive, even more so than 19.5 times sales, let alone earnings (want to TSX: SHOP?). Good on the ownership for Verafin for cashing out.

The article laments how Canadian technology companies get taken away, but this is a result of Canada’s regulatory and paternalistic climate – structurally designed to strongly favour incumbency entrenchment and throw talent that can innovate to the USA.

Bearish media

Stock market tops are formed on euphoria and seeing people that have no business in investing making tons of money on Nikola (Nasdaq: NKLA) through call options.

The financial media loves to assign opinions to you, so here is what they’ve assigned to me this Friday:

Don’t panic, but be prepared. An investors’ survival guide for the unstable, uncertain and volatile months ahead
Investors should brace for an extended period of stock market volatility
Attention millennial investors of the pandemic: It’s time to sell your tech stock winners

Sounds like there’s a bit of steam left.

Back to normal – and re-indexing

Examining the price action of the past couple business days, I think there is a better chance than not that we have received the “flush-out” that I wrote about last week. The morning was packed with market selling before everything went up again. S&P 500 volatility spiked up to the 40% level. The trading was a bit panicky in two waves (how appropriate for COVID-19!). For the most part, I have been content to watch. There might be another ‘wave’ but I think the slow and gradual force exhibited by the central banks will force more capital into the markets.

I have been mildly tweaking my portfolio here and there, but in very minor ways. I’ve lightened up my USD portfolio concentration slightly.

Finally, I note that the TSX will be re-indexing their TSX 60 and Composite indexes next week. I always look at the entrails of index discards because typically if a company is getting trashed out of the index, the stock price tanks because of the automatic supply that gets sent to the market. However, if the underlying company has value, this is a better time than not to add. The only problem is a bunch of other institutional investors do exactly the same thing (reducing the effectiveness of this technique). Needless to say, there is a lot of money passively tracking the TSX 60 and TSX Composite, but most of it is concentrated in the top names.

How do you get into the TSX Composite? (I’ll just do a cut-and-paste job here):

To be eligible for inclusion in the S&P/TSX Composite, a security must meet the following two criteria:

1. Based on the volume weighted average price (VWAP) of the security on the Toronto Stock Exchange over the last 10 trading days of the month-end prior to the Quarterly Review, the security must represent a minimum weight of 0.04% of the index, after including the Quoted Market Value (QMV) of that security in the total float capitalization of the index. In the event that any Index Security has a weight of more than 10% at any month-end, the minimum weights for the purpose of inclusion are based on the S&P/TSX Capped Composite.

2. The security must have a minimum VWAP of C$1 over the past three months and over the last 10 trading days of the month-end prior to the Quarterly Review.

… and to get kicked out:

For Quarterly Review deletions the following buffer rules apply.

1. To be eligible for continued inclusion in the index, a security must meet the following two criteria:
a. Based on the volume weighted average price (VWAP) over the last 10 trading days of the month-end prior to the Quarterly Review, the security must represent a minimum weight of 0.025% of the index, after including the QMV for that security in the total float capitalization for the index. In the event that any Index Security has a weight of more than 10% at any month-end, the minimum weights for the purpose of inclusion are based on the S&P/TSX Capped Composite.
b. The security must have a minimum VWAP of C$1 over the previous three calendar months.

2. Liquidity is measured by float turnover (total number of shares traded in Canada and U.S. in the previous 12 months divided by float-adjusted shares outstanding at the end of the period). Liquidity must be at least 0.25. For dual-listed stocks, liquidity must also be at least 0.125 when using Canadian volume only.

In case if you were wondering, for the overall composite Index, Royal Bank is still 6% of the TSX and Shopify is currently around 5%, so no fears of over-concentration. I remember at one point Nortel was above 20% of the TSX.

Deleted out of the TSX Composite are:
AFN – Ag Growth International
AD – Alaris Royalty
BTE – Baytex Energy
BBD.B – Bombardier
CHE.UN – Chemtrade Logistics
CHR – Chorus Aviation
EFX – Enerflex
EXE – Extendicare
FRU – Freehold Royalties
FEC – Frontera Energy
HEXO – HEXO
MTY – MTY Food Group
SES – Secure Energy Services
SCL – Shawcor

I will offer some mild and not-so-useful commentary – some of these are compelling values. Some of them I’ve written about here before. I’ve looked at the inclusions and don’t like any of them.