Blackberry / Prem Watsa

The whole investment world knows about what is going on with Blackberry. They reported their quarterly result today and it indeed was the disaster the company signalled last week, which wasn’t a surprise to the marketplace. Indeed, optimists that were wearing glasses with a very deep hue of rose could pick out some elements that did not lead to total despair, but the pickings are slim.

My post is a very simple one – Prem Watsa’s very conditional US$9/share offer is genuine. There is a whole bunch of speculation why it will fall through, and these are legitimate (mainly there needs to be other CANADIAN backers in this offer other than Fairfax, who have already been badly singed with the acquisition of their 10% stake in the firm). However, one risk that media brings up which I do not believe to be a risk is the genuineness of Watsa’s intentions. I have been following Fairfax for over a decade, and it simply does not pay from a reputational standpoint for Watsa to be playing “games” on this one. It would harm his company’s future ability to pull off similar acquisitions.

With Blackberry trading at about $8/share, this would leave about 12-13% upside over a two month time frame. There is an outside chance (I’d weight this as roughly 25% at present) of other bidders coming into the foray, which would likely not be in the form of a clean takeout offer.

Watsa also has to consider if this deal falls through what he will do with his 52 million share stake in Blackberry, still worth around $420 million at current market value. He has about as much of an incentive to see something happen with his stake as the rest of the shareholders do.